Tyler McCall of Paper & Pencil AND Chicago Stationery Fest

As the economy flounders and the election cycle drags on, many makers and retailers in the stationery space are simply navigating their way through the best they can. But stationery success stories still happen! Tyler McCall and his husband and business partner Eric Campbell have been on an upward trajectory since opening their 400-square-foot shop in the Andersonville neighborhood of Chicago, Paper & Pencil, in May 2023.

The two built the highly curated Paper & Pencil on their own terms, and when attending the New York markets for the first time in Winter 2024, the first kernel of Chicago Stationery Fest was planted. Happening March 22 and 23, 2025, this consumer-facing event may just break down the “trade-only” wall to let paper nerds in the wild experience the magic that the stationery trade has privately enjoyed for decades.

While Chicago Stationery Fest is just one of several similar events popping up around the country, its springtime dates also lend themselves to the wholesale buying that for this category has always occurred during this specific window. It all begs the question, are we are on the verge of a stationery renaissance?

  1. I finally got a chance to listen to this whole Paper and Pencil interview and I loved it. I love that you’re not online! I know just where you are — I was born in Lincoln Park and grew up in the Chicago area. I love the look of your shop inside too! I see great things ahead for you. (I’m your new Instagram follower!) Thanks, Sarah, for always finding the great stuff.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Subscribe